The Subway Series rolls into the Bronx as the New York Yankees host the New York Mets on Sunday, September 13, 2026, at Yankee Stadium. First pitch is set for 1:35 PM ET, with the game airing on YES and SNY. Yankees right-hander Cam Schlittler draws the start opposite Mets hurler Christian Scott. With September racing toward its final weeks, every game in this rivalry carries added weight in the regular season standings — and a sellout crowd at Yankee Stadium will be making sure both clubs feel it.
Yankees vs. Mets Game Preview: Sunday, September 13, 2026
Probable Starting Pitchers
The Yankees will hand the ball to Cam Schlittler, one of the younger arms to work their way into the rotation picture in the Bronx. Schlittler has shown flashes of a promising arsenal, and a Subway Series start at Yankee Stadium is precisely the kind of stage that can define a young pitcher's season — for better or worse. The pressure is real. The crowd is loud. How he handles it matters.
For New York's other team, Christian Scott takes the mound for the Mets. Scott is a right-hander who has demonstrated the ability to generate swing-and-miss stuff at the big-league level. The Yankees lineup will need to be disciplined early, work counts, and avoid letting Scott settle into a rhythm in the first few innings. Getting to the Mets bullpen at a reasonable pitch count would be a win in itself for New York's offense.
Keys to Watch for the Yankees
- Schlittler's command: A young starter facing a Mets lineup in a rivalry game needs to attack the zone. Walks and deep counts will put the Yankees defense in difficult situations. Schlittler must stay ahead in the count to be effective.
- Offensive patience against Scott: Scott can overpower hitters when he gets ahead early. The Yankees need to grind at-bats, make him work, and look for opportunities to do damage in hitter's counts rather than chasing his offspeed offerings out of the zone.
- Bullpen depth: If Schlittler exits before the sixth inning, the Yankees bullpen will face the Mets in a high-stakes Sunday afternoon game. Managing arms late in the regular season is a balancing act, and the Yankees brass will need to be sharp with their decisions.
- Home atmosphere: Yankee Stadium on a Sunday afternoon for the Subway Series is one of baseball's best environments. The Yankees have historically fed off that energy — the roster needs to channel it from the first pitch.
Prediction
This is a genuine toss-up built around two young starters who have something to prove. The edge goes to the Yankees at home, where the crowd and the familiarity of Yankee Stadium provide a real advantage. If Schlittler can give the Yankees five competitive innings and the offense does enough early damage against Scott, the Bronx Bombers take this one. Yankees win, 4–2.
Catch all the action on YES Network, SNY, or on WFAN 660/101.9 FM.
